- The Multidisciplined
- Posts
- šø Battle of the Bots: Dall-E 3 vs. Midjourney
šø Battle of the Bots: Dall-E 3 vs. Midjourney
Which tool is best for your image generation needs?
The TLDR
Highlight: This week, weāre cross-testing ChatGPTās new Dall-E 3 extension against the market leader, Midjourney, to see how it stacks up.
Musing of the Week: Meta is rolling out AI characters based on celebrities like Snoop Dogg, Tom Brady, Kendall Jenner, and MrBeast. Creepy or cool - what do you think?
Editorial Style photo, Bird's eye, Retro Diner, Home Diner, Vintage Decor, Checkered Floors, Neon Signs, Close-up, Retro Diner Hues, Vintage Collectibles, Soft natural, Home diner, Evening, Nostalgic, Retro Diner
š£ Head to Head: Dall-E 3 Vs. Midjourney
ChatGPTās new Dall-E 3 extension just dropped for the general public. Weāve been using Midjourney pretty frequently for a few months now, but we were excited to test an integrated solution. From pricing to image quality, weāll compare the two models to see which one weāre likely to move forward with.
š° Pricing
Dall-E 3: $20/month with ChatGPT Plus or free with Bing Chat
Midjourney: Starts at $10/month
š® Ease of Use
Dall-E 3 wins on user-friendliness thanks to its conversational interface. The tradeoff here is that unless you specifically tell the Chat not to modify your prompt, it will try to rewrite it. Sometimes, this ends up being more like meddling, turning your unique prompt into something more generic. While itās harder to learn Midjourney because it lacks a conversational layer, the customization seems deeper, especially once you master the nuances of prompt creation.
A high-quality cartoon image of a dog jumping up to catch a ball, high-quality Pixar cartoon
šØ Output Quality
Both are lightyears ahead of last year's tech, but Midjourney has retained its edge in quality. Dall-E 3 keeps up in cartoon styles, but if you're after a more photorealistic look, Midjourney wins. Dall-E 3 is still pretty firmly stuck in the uncanny valley.
Regardless, for most applications, youāll be able to get a decent image out of either model as long as youāre willing to spend time regenerating.
8k photograph of a family in a field of grass, taken at golden hour, high-quality photograph, Nikon D850
šø Digging Deeper
Composition:
We were optimistic about the ability to control compositions, but both Dall-E 3 and Midjourney fell short. They're keyword-focused and donāt have a general understanding of the images. This means you might find yourself in a loop, getting variations of the same image over and over. For instance, in the images below no matter how many times we regenerated, both platforms insisted on placing the sun in the center of the frame.
8k photograph of a family in a field of grass, taken at golden hour, high-quality photograph, Nikon D850
Style:
Both adapt well to style instructions. However, Dall-E 3 tends to add a CGI-like sheen even when you don't want it. While we could probably avoid this by building more specific prompts and telling Dall-E not to modify them, that eliminates its usability advantage.
š The Bottom Line
So, Dall-E 3 or Midjourney? It really comes down to what you're afterāsimplicity or customizability. As for us, we'll likely stick with Midjourney for most of our needs. But since Dall-E 3 comes pre-bundled with our GPT Plus subscription, weāll certainly find some opportunities to make use of it in our projects.
If a straightforward, easy-to-use platform is what you're looking for, Dall-E 3 is an easy choice.
But if high quality and greater control over your creations is a priority, we'd give the win to Midjourney.
š§ Musing of the Week
Meta is making significant strides in AI, focusing heavily on the consumer market. The tech giant is unveiling AI avatars, conversational aides for WhatsApp, Messenger, and Instagram, image editing tools, and, notably, AI personas crafted in the likeness of cultural icons and influencers like Snoop Dogg and Kendall Jenner.
These lifelike AI characters have different names than their human counterparts - for example, Kendall Jenner is āBillieā, and Charlie DāAmelio has become āCoco.ā If you start an Instagram DM with one of these characters, they are very explicit about their āpurpose.ā Billie is an older sister and confidante, and Coco is a dance queen/coach. This gives us pause regarding the intended role of these characters, the userās objectives, and potential unintended outcomes.
On the bright side, these characters could potentially help tackle todayās loneliness epidemic. Billie, for example, is here to listen to your troubles and offer advice without complaint. In theory, sheās the perfect friend. Is this really any different from the primarily text message-based relationships we have with our āreal friendsā?
However, there's a flip side. Netizens have already expressed how ācreepyā these characters are, especially as it creates pathways to more intense parasocial relationships, given these characters mirror real celebrities that people actually want to bond with. This can heighten a distorted sense of reality, fuel obsessive fan tendencies, and foster illusionsāor rather delusionsāof friendship.
Meta promises to roll out AI slowly and with safeguards - do you trust Meta?
Kendall Jenner has become āBillie,ā an older sister and confidante
š If youāre hyped about the generative AI industry specifically, here are some of the coolest roles weāve seen this week:
šØ Check out these other AI tools weāve been looking at this week:
Gibbly - AI-driven game-based learning and lesson planning
Outboundly - Cold emails and LinkedIn messages in one click
MindPal - Upload your work information and use AI to interact with it
Thatās all for this week. See you next Tuesday!
Lorel & Reily